No more Journey psych-outs
I kept that in mind today as I read this snippet of note from a Chris Haft mailbag (I'm still holding out hope for some kind of anti-Draper).
On some extremely good teams, Feliz might indeed be a utilityman. But the power-starved Giants need the pop Feliz provides, however inconsistently. For better or worse, he averaged 21 home runs the past three seasons. Feliz's biggest problem in 2006 was insufficient rest. With Aurilia and perhaps Kevin Frandsen available to give him a break -- and with Klesko handy, as you said, to play first when Aurilia isn't there -- Feliz should remain fresh and potentially more productive this season.
OK, so maybe I don't agree that the Giants need the pop Feliz provides. Remember he was the Worst Third Baseman in the Major Leagues last season. Even 98 RBIs don't mean that much with a 3.8 RC/27.
But the idea that it was overuse that drove him to it (Steve Perry, Steeeeeve Perry) is intriguing. Feliz was never great at getting on base (04-06 line: .256/.293/.443), but if he has to play can we not try to make it better?
So I checked the Day-by-Day database to see how Feliz did as the season progressed, and by damn he did get noticebly worse as the days wore on.
April-June
| BA | OBA | Slug% | OPS | SB% | AB/HR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| .275 | .306 | .476 | .782 | - | 26.08 |
July-October
| BA | OBA | Slug% | OPS | SB% | AB/HR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| .216 | .260 | .395 | .655 | 50.00 | 26.91 |
And here's how his OBP broke down by month:
May: .336
June: .320
July: .291
August: .263
September: .223
His May was actually pretty good. He finished a .308/.336./.564 line, hitting seven home runs with 21 RBI. Small sample size and all, if he good do that all year I would have no problem with him.
The big problem was that no other month came close. After his .900 OPS in may he never got within .100 points any other month, finishing with a .504 OPS in 98 September AB.
Conclusion: Yeah, Feliz may have been worn down last year. But it just made a bad player worse. Even looking at his career-highs, a monster Feliz would be something like .280/.310./520, and that's with rounding-up all his season-highs.
Those numbers would put him somewhere between Brandon Inge and Joe Crede. Those numbers are also completely unrealistic.
What's more likely is that the new platoons give Feliz some more rest and he continues his sloptastic ways at a slightly less nausea-inducing pace. Though the platoons may not even be the reason. Bill James, CHONE, Marcel and ZiPS all project him to improve his OBP next year, so it may just be random chance.
But put me down for not-Joe Crede.


